Homelessness is a Bioethical Issue

Nicole Fice makes a case for understanding homelessness as an issue for bioethics.

__________________________________________

Homelessness is the situation of an individual, family or community living without safe, stable, permanent, and appropriate housing. Despite challenges relating to measuring homelessness, rates of homelessness have been increasing across Canada. A recent report in Ontario showed that homelessness has increased more than 23% in the last four years and is projected to increased by more than 15% in the next three years. Homelessness has also been a key issue in municipal elections across Ontario.

Homelessness is not the result of decisions at the individual level. Homelessness cannot be solely explained by substance use or mental health issues either, as the relationship between these issues is complex and compounding. Rather, the causes of homelessness are systemic and multifaceted.

The rise of homelessness, especially in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic, has been driven by poor housing affordability, higher unemployment, and higher overall costs of living caused by inflation. Yet the rise of homelessness since 2020 may only be partially attributable to the pandemic. Indeed, some argue that the pandemic only served to make homelessness, especially unsheltered and emergency sheltered homelessness, much more visible, as sheltering in indoor shelters became unsafe.

Photo Credit: Ted McGrath/flickr. Image Description: A photo of a tent encampment in Canada.

There are a variety of health risks for persons experiencing homelessness, especially chronic unsheltered homelessness. These include higher risk of acquiring an infectious disease and premature death. Importantly, the connection between homelessness and health is bi-directional. Experiencing homelessness makes it more difficult to access health care services, while also leading to greater health risks. Experiencing such risks can drive up the need to access health care. So, someone’s health status can put them at a higher risk of experiencing homelessness, and homelessness creates new health problems and makes existing ones worse.

Some populations are at an elevated risk of experiencing homelessness, including Indigenous people, Black Canadians, people with disabilities, newcomers and refugees, people who identify 2SLGBTQ+ (especially youth), and more. It is important to examine homelessness through an intersectional lens, as people might belong to multiple social groups at risk of experiencing homelessness.

Homelessness raises a myriad of pressing ethical challenges and dilemmas. Consider first the increased risks of poorer health outcomes among people experiencing homelessness. These risks are health inequities that we ought to address. These concerns and others have led experts to label homelessness as a public health issue, something that should be addressed and prevented through collective action.

Another issue relates to the higher use of emergency departments (EDs) in hospitals by people experiencing homelessness. This higher use raises interesting questions about how people experiencing homelessness are (and should be) treated in EDs and how service providers experience moral distress in facing this issue. Further, when visits to EDs lead people experiencing homelessness to be admitted to hospital, evidence suggests their stays are longer and costlier. One question here is how EDs should address the prevalence of people experiencing homelessness seeking care. In 2024, the University Health Network in Toronto opened Canada’s first social medicine housing initiative, Dunn House, in partnership with local service providers. Dunn House provides highly supportive and affordable housing to people with complex medical and social needs. It has proven effective at reducing ED visits and is set to expand. Initiatives such as Dunn House are important components of a robust and evidence-informed response to homelessness that recognize housing is intricately tied to peoples’ health.

There are also ethical issues regarding how homelessness is responded to at the policy level. Consider, for example, municipal bylaws that prohibit tenting or sheltering in public spaces, which are used to dismantle and displace people living in homeless encampments. These approaches have been legally challenged across Canada and there is work on the degree to which these are evidence-informed approaches, but there is little work on the ethical implications of such approaches. There are many other policies that have been proposed, and implemented in practice, that aim to address homelessness. Other proposed policies appeal to ethical concepts and call for ethical approaches, yet they are not always connected to literature in ethics on the same concepts.

Homelessness is a profound injustice, both in distributive and non-distributive terms. In wealthy countries like Canada, many people are left without access to safe, stable, affordable, and adequate housing, while the housing sector prospers. This contrast is significant, given that Canada arguably has the means to provide such housing. We can trace these problems to the extreme wealth inequality that exists in countries like Canada. Homelessness is also an extreme form of marginalization and social exclusion, which raises significant questions about how our society treats and ought to treat its most vulnerable people. It also raises questions about when and how our society recognizes and respects the rights and dignity of people, and the consequences of failing to do so.

Homelessness is an issue that our society must address urgently. The Canadian Government recognizes this through funding announced in the latest Budget. However, we should endeavour to address homelessness in ways that are ethically informed. Bioethicists could make (and continue to make) important contributions in this regard alongside other experts and advocates.

__________________________________________

Nicole Fice is an Assistant Professor in the School of Health Studies at Western University.