Still Alice meets Still Gloria

Françoise Baylis reflects on the book Still Alice.


Beverly Beckham of The Boston Globe writes in praise of Lisa Genova’s Still Alice “‘You have to get this book’ … I couldn’t put it down…”

After I read Still Alice, a book of fiction about an accomplished Harvard professor with early-onset Alzheimer’s disease, I too wanted to tell everyone to get this book (and I did once have a chance to do so in a radio interview with Rex Murphy), but not because “I couldn’t put it down”. The first time I read this book I put it down several times to stop and cry. It was too painful to read in one stretch. My mother – Gloria Baylis – had recently been diagnosed with Alzheimer’s disease and vascular dementia. Alice Howland’s story was both too familiar (in terms of what I already knew) and too revealing (in terms of what I did not yet know).

I first read this book in 2011 while living in New Zealand. Before I left my home in Halifax for Dunedin, I flew to Montreal to say goodbye to my mother who was by now a resident of Sunrise – a nursing home with a special program for persons with Alzheimer’s and memory difficulties. I took a taxi from the airport directly to the nursing home. I found my Mom wandering the hall, a common behaviour among persons with Alzheimer’s. She looked somewhat confused when she saw me, and stared at the travel suitcase I had with me. She asked me if I was leaving. I told her “yes” I was leaving on a long trip, but not today. Today, I had come for a quick visit with her. I reminded her that I was going to New Zealand for a year. I had explained this to her about two weeks ago in a face-to-face conversation during the Christmas holidays. She turned to me and said, “I don’t know what you just told me, but all of a sudden I don’t feel well.” When I left the next day, I didn’t know if I would see my mother again. As it happens, there were no dramatic events that year and my mother is still alive today – 11 years after the initial diagnosis and the fateful pronouncement “there is no cure.”

feature_image_sa_cover1With Alzheimer’s there are a few drugs that may slow the rate of cognitive decline, but there is no magic to stop it or reverse it. The most recent statistics, as provided by the Alzheimer Society of Canada, confirm that in 2011 there were 747,000 Canadians living with Alzheimer’s.

I don’t remember who told me to read Still Alice. I do remember that I wished I had read it much earlier. The book helped me to better understand the fear and isolation experienced by persons with Alzheimer’s as they slowly lose their mind. I would like to believe that with this better understanding, I might have had kinder, gentler interactions with my mother while she was in the early stages of dementia and merely suffering from “disorientation, mental confusion and memory lapses.” I might have had one or two less arguments with her about the “facts.” I might not have done or said whatever prompted her to say to me one day in a pained voice “I’m still a person.”

In reading Still Alice not only did I learn how frightening Alzheimer’s is for the person who is afflicted, I also learned that there is a pattern to this ugly, unkind disease. Still Alice poignantly recounts the slow progression of debilitating symptoms, punctuated by staggering losses. Both Alice and Gloria experienced not being able to find their way home — a place they had lived for years and years. Both experienced frustration at not being able to make a Christmas dessert they had made without a recipe for years and years. Both experienced gut wrenching emotional pain when they were told that their mother had died, not remembering that this had happened years and years ago.

In closing, Still Alice is a story about memory, belonging, and recognition. Alzheimer’s disease robs the person of memory. Whether it also robs her of belonging and recognition is up to us—all of us. A few years ago, when struggling to know me, my mother said “you belong to me.” She was very right about this. And, just as I belong to her, “she belongs to me.” What is needed for persons with Alzheimer’s to retain a meaningful place in the world is that they belong and be recognized by others.

To echo Beckham, Still Alice “isn’t only about dementia. It’s about Alice, a woman beloved by her family and respected by her colleagues who, in the end, is still Alice, not just her disease.” My mother is still Gloria, not just her disease. All persons with Alzheimer’s are themselves, not just their disease. When I read Still Alice, I hear my mother saying to me “I’m still Gloria, Gloria in Excelsis Deo.” My mother loved this familiar refrain.


Françoise Baylis is a Professor and Canada Research Chair in Bioethics and Philosophy at Dalhousie University @FrancoiseBaylis

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: